A Comprehensive Guide to Tamron 18-200 vs Canon 18-135 Lens: Which is Better?

When it comes to choosing between the Tamron 18-200mm and the Canon 18-135mm lenses, the question of which is better is not as straightforward as one might think. Both are popular choices in the entry-level to mid-range market, and each has its own unique features that cater to different photographic needs.

Overview and Quality Differences

The concept of determining which lens is outright 'better' can be misleading. Both Tamron and Canon have their own glass factories and continue to produce high-quality glass. The true quality lies in the final product, and in reality, most users evaluate their photographs on monitors displaying at a 72 dpi resolution. Therefore, the differences can often be quite subtle and depend on individual usage scenarios.

Focusing on focal length, the Tamron 18-200mm lens offers a wider range of use, particularly excelling at capturing distant subjects. However, the 135mm end of the Canon 18-135mm lens, while not extending as high, can still provide excellent results for distance photography. Ultimately, the choice often comes down to personal financial considerations. In the past, lenses from third-party brands like Tamron, Sigma, and Tokina were often labeled as 'pirate lenses,' but today, they offer high-quality finishes and durable exteriors that match or exceed those of native brand lenses.

Personal Preferences Matter

Deciding between the two lenses is a deeply personal choice that depends on your photography preferences. If you have specific needs or preferences, let's explore more information. For instance, do you shoot landscapes, sports, portraits, or wildlife? Understanding your needs will help in making the best decision.

Canon 18-135mm: A Well-Rounded Lens

I would lean towards the Canon 18-135mm lens. I prioritize image quality over the extended range of the Tamron. Additionally, the Canon lens is faster and lighter, which can be advantageous in various shooting scenarios. If you already own a Canon 18-135mm and are satisfied with its performance, you might consider sticking with a native Canon lens for better compatibility and possibly less maintenance.

Tamron 18-200mm: Savings and Performance

Considering the Tamron 18-200mm lens, I would choose this option for saving money, especially if I read positive reviews. Many users have been pleased with this lens, even going on to purchase additional Tamron lenses. The quality and durability of the Tamron lenses have improved significantly, with fewer issues than in the past.

Conclusion and Recommendations

Ultimately, the decision between the Tamron 18-200mm and the Canon 18-135mm lens comes down to your personal needs and budget. If you value image quality and don't need the extended range, the Canon 18-135mm might be the better choice. Conversely, if you are looking for a lens that can do more with less money, the Tamron 18-200mm is an excellent option.

For a more detailed comparison, please refer to the sample photographs taken with both lenses. I encourage you to make a decision based on your specific needs and budget, as each lens has its strengths and weaknesses suited to different photographic situations.