Are Kailh and Gateron Clones of Cherry MX Switches Superior or Inferior?
When it comes to mechanical keyboard switches, the Cherry MX Switches have long stood as the gold standard in terms of quality and reliability. However, with the rise of Kailh and Gateron clone switches, many keyboard enthusiasts are now exploring alternatives. In this article, we delve into whether these clones, particularly Kailh and Gateron, surpass the original Cherry MX switches in terms of performance and user experience.
Smoothing the Experience: Smoothness and Tactile Quality
Mechanical keyboard enthusiasts often prioritize the smoothness and tactile quality of their switches. Based on numerous reviews and my personal experience, Kailh switches generally tend to be smoother than their Cherry counterparts. This is largely due to the use of polyoxymethylene (POM) in Kailh switch housings, which exhibit a lower coefficient of friction compared to the plastics used in Cherry switches. The result is a smoother and more refined typing experience, which can be particularly beneficial for those in need of a more gentle transition and tactile feel.
Click and Clack: Is the Clicked Sound Superior?
For users who favor clicky switches, the Kailh switch's clickbar mechanism offers a marked advantage over the plastic click mechanisms found in Cherry switches. The clickbar, which is made of metal, provides a clearer, louder, and more satisfying click. This difference is not just a matter of perception; it translates into a more pronounced and satisfying typing experience. Users often report that Kailh clicky switches sound and feel noticeably better than their Cherry equivalents, enhancing the overall experience of the keyboard.
Weighted and Balanced: Comparing Reds and Blacks
The Cherry MX Reds and Blacks have long been lauded for their balanced and weighted feel, but in some cases, the original switches may fall short. For Cherry MX Reds, the spring strength can be a matter of concern, with some users finding the keycaps too light. Conversely, Cherry MX Blacks are known for their strong spring, which can be too heavy for some users. These imperfections in the original Cherry switches present an opportunity for improvement in the clone market.
In comparison, both Kailh and Gateron switches tend to offer a superior balance. Many users find that the design of these clones allows for a more uniform and consistent tactile response. Specifically, Kailh switches are often praised for their ability to strike a better balance between lightness and robustness, making them a favorite among those looking for a precise and satisfying typing experience.
Conclusion: Quality and Typing Feel
In conclusion, the evidence suggests that, in many cases, Kailh and Gateron clones have indeed surpassed their original Cherry MX counterparts in terms of quality and typing feel. The use of POM in Kailh switches, the superior clickbar mechanism, and a better balance in switch weights all contribute to an overall superior user experience. However, it's important to note that the performance of these clones may vary based on individual preferences, so conducting one's own testing and evaluations is recommended before making a decision.
Final Thoughts
The relentless pursuit of the perfect mechanical keyboard switch continues, and Kailh and Gateron clones certainly hold their ground, if not surpass, in some cases. For those weighing their options, these alternatives offer a promising leap forward in terms of smoothness, click quality, and balanced typing performance.