Choosing Between HP Envy x360 and Dell Inspiron 7586: A Comparative Review
When it comes to evaluating mid-priced 2 in 1 laptops, the choice between the HP Envy x360 and Dell Inspiron 7586 can be quite confusing, especially when both models come equipped with similar specifications such as the i5-8250/8265, 256 GB SSD, 8 GB RAM, and Dell UHD 1080p 60Hz display. This article delves into the key aspects you should consider such as battery life, screen quality, and build quality to make an informed decision.
Battery Life
For a 2 in 1 laptop to be truly versatile, it must offer long battery life. Both the HP Envy x360 and Dell Inspiron 7586 are equipped with similar batteries, but concerns arise regarding the thermals (heat dissipation).
Thermal management is a critical factor that can significantly impact overall performance. Poor airflow and inadequate cooling systems can lead to overheating, ultimately degrading the processor's performance. For instance, a thin Core i9 laptop has demonstrated performance worse and sluggishly when compared to a Core i7 lap top. The Dell has a history of poor thermal performance, with my old Dell Inspiron 2x1 (2017 model) experiencing significant heat issues despite having an 8th generation processor. My gaming Alienware laptops, with a 7th generation processor, performed far better in processor-intensive tasks.
If thermal management does not concern you, the use case is mostly for productivity without video editing or 3D rendering, both of these laptops should suffice, albeit with caution about high temperatures. Temperatures around 60 degrees Celsius may be acceptable for occasional use but could become uncomfortable with regular usage.
Screen Quality
Screen quality remains a crucial aspect when deciding between the two 2 in 1 laptops. Both the HP Envy x360 and Dell Inspiron 7586 come with 1080p UHD displays, providing a decent visual experience suitable for productivity tasks and general use. However, the quality of the displays can vary over time due to various factors such as screen durability.
From personal experience, the Dell Inspiron 7586 has faced issues such as a sticky trackpad and a keyboard with keys sticking after only a few months of use. Additionally, the screen of the Inspiron 7586 has shown signs of wear such as a cracked screen from gentle use. The hinge on the Inspiron 7586 also stopped functioning after three months of moderate use, which could be a significant limitation for users who want to use the device as a tablet.
Build Quality
Both the HP Envy x360 and Dell Inspiron 7586 are built with metal frames, providing a durable and premium feel. However, the build quality can vary, and personal experiences play a significant role in evaluating this aspect.
The Dell Inspiron 7586 in particular has encountered several quality issues. The trackpad and keyboard became unusably sticky after four months, and the screen cracked under gentle handling. The 2x1 hinge also failed after just three months of use. In contrast, my friend with the HP Envy x360 has had a more positive experience, with the laptop being used for two years without significant issues. However, since I have not personally used an HP Envy 2 in 1, I cannot provide first-hand experience.
For a truly reliable and long-lasting 2 in 1 laptop, you might consider alternative options. If you are looking for a premium option, Razer Blade Stealth is a top choice. For a mid-range alternative with excellent value for money, you may consider the GPD Pocket V1 or V2. For high-end enthusiasts, Microsoft Surface is a great option.
Given the factors discussed, unless you are specifically dedicated to one of the mentioned models, I recommend either opting for a Razer Blade Stealth or the GPD Pocket V1 or V2, depending on your budget and requirements.