Choosing the Best Laptop: Surface Pro 3 or MacBook 12-Inch?
Navigating the choice between a new 12-inch MacBook and the Surface Pro 3 can be challenging, especially for tech enthusiasts who are weighing the pros and cons of each device. This article aims to provide a comprehensive comparison, helping you make an informed decision based on your needs and preferences.
Operating Systems and Security
When considering the operating systems, macOS on the MacBook is far more secure and superior compared to Windows on the Surface Pro 3. macOS is renowned for its robust security features and protection against viruses. It's nearly hack-proof, much like an iPhone, which has been testified by the FBI and NSA. This makes it an excellent choice for users who prioritize privacy and security.
For those seeking the ultimate in security and convenience, models that have the Touch Bar with integrated Touch ID and a T2 or higher security chip (similar to the Secure Enclave in iPhones) are highly recommended. This dual-layer protection ensures both hardware and software security is maintained at the highest level.
Mobile Footprint vs. Desktop Compatibility
The choice between the MacBook and Surface Pro 3 depends largely on your current primary computing device. If you're a Windows user with a Windows phone, the Surface Pro 3 would be the better choice. Conversely, if you use an iPhone or an Android device, the MacBook might be more in line with your needs.
For users with an Android device, the decision should also consider your desktop setup. If you run Windows on your desktop, the Surface Pro 3 would be a solid choice. However, if you use macOS on your desktop, the MacBook is the hands-down winner due to seamless integration and compatibility with various macOS apps and tools.
Device Features and Performance
While both the MacBook and Surface Pro 3 offer decent performance, they cater to different user needs. The Surface Pro 3 is notably better as a tablet, thanks to its touchscreen, whereas the MacBook features a more comfortable and responsive keyboard. Here are some key differences to consider:
Performance: The Surface Pro 3 offers three processor options (i3, i5, i7) with clock speeds ranging from 1.5 GHz to 1.9 GHz. The MacBook 12-inch, on the other hand, features Intel M processors with clock speeds of 1.11 GHz, 1.2 GHz, and 1.3 GHz, which might provide better battery life. Screen: The Surface Pro 3 is a touchscreen device, making it suitable for graphic designers, video editors, and content creators. The MacBook does not have a touchscreen, but it offers a more traditional laptop experience with a high-quality, responsive display. Keyboard: The MacBook's keyboard is generally preferred for continuous use, offering a more natural typing experience. In contrast, the Surface Pro 3's integrated keyboard might not be as comfortable or responsive for prolonged typing sessions. Ports: The MacBook 12-inch comes with a single USB-C port that also serves as a charging port, requiring adapters for other USB devices. The Surface Pro 3, however, retains traditional USB 2.0 and 3.0 ports, eliminating the need for additional adapters.Final Decision
Ultimately, your choice between the Surface Pro 3 and MacBook 12-inch will depend on several factors, including your preferred operating system, the amount of processing power needed, the type of screen you prefer, your typing habits, and the need for ports and adaptors.
Conclusion
The MacBook 12-inch is consistently the better choice for most users who prioritize security, seamless integration, and a native Mac environment. However, if you are an engineering student who requires cross-platform support and potent software compatibility, the Surface Pro 3 could be a better fit.