MacBook Pro vs Surface Book: Weighty Considerations for Ideal User Experience
When it comes to choosing between the MacBook Pro and Surface Book, several key factors determine which machine best suits your needs. This article will explore the pros and cons of both devices, helping you make an informed decision based on objective and subjective factors.
Objective Superiority: Features and Performance
Higher Resolution Screen
The MacBook Pro offers a higher resolution screen, which is a significant advantage for those who demand pixel-perfect clarity and detail in their work or entertainment. The Surface Book, while not falling short, lags slightly in this department.
Touchscreen Technology
For 2018 and now 2023 and beyond, nearly every laptop comes with a touchscreen feature. The Surface Book includes a touchscreen that adds versatility and multi-functionality to the device.
Versatility and Tablet Mode
The Surface Book transforms into a tablet mode effortlessly, which is highly beneficial for those who frequently switch between desktop and mobile computing. The MacBook Pro lacks this feature, which may be limiting.
Optional Battery Life and Adaptability
The MacBook Pro excels in battery life, especially when powered by the desktop mode. Thanks to its dual battery design, you can use the tablet part of the laptop independently, extending your battery life significantly. The Surface Book 2 includes a single USB Type-C, but it does support Type-C in the future, offering more flexibility.
Updated Ports and Connectivity
The MacBook Pro comes with a range of current ports, making it more versatile for various peripherals. While USB Type-C is the future, the majority of peripherals still use traditional USB and HDMI ports. This means the laptop may require dongles and adapters, which can detract from portability. The Surface Book 2 has 2 USB 3.0 ports and a full-sized SD card reader, providing more connectivity options.
Subjective Superiority: User Experience Factors
Operating System
The Surface Book runs Windows 10, which may be preferable for those who prefer the flexibility and compatibility that comes with Windows. The MacBook Pro runs macOS, which is optimal for those who prioritize reliability and a seamless user experience.
Surface Pen Support
The Surface Pen, with 4096 levels of pressure sensitivity, is ideal for graphic designers and artists. This stylus directly integrates with the screen, providing a more intuitive and precise input method.
Security Features
The Surface Book 2 includes a Windows Hello infrared camera for biometric security. While some users prefer fingerprint sensors, the Microsoft solution offers a unique and modern security feature.
Design and Aesthetics
The Surface Book 2 has a more unique design, particularly the "fulcrum hinge" that adds to its appeal. The MacBook Pro, while sleek, remains more conventional.
Keyboard and Comfort
The Surface Book 2 features a more typewriter-style keyboard with a fair amount of key travel, which can be more comfortable for extended use compared to the MacBook Pro.
Cons of the Surface Book
Despite its advantages, the Surface Book is also more expensive, larger, thicker, and heavier than the MacBook Pro. It's a trade-off for those who prioritize portability.
Comparing Other Laptops
While the MacBook Pro and Surface Book are the primary contenders, there are other laptops to consider, such as the HP Spectre series and HP ZBook x2. These laptops provide alternative solutions with distinct advantages, catering to specific user needs.
The beauty of having options MacBook Pro and Surface Book brings diverse choices to the market. They each excel in different aspects, making it a matter of personal choice and specific needs.