Navigating InDesign CS4 Incompatibility on macOS High Sierra

Transitioning to a new macOS version like macOS High Sierra can seem straightforward, but it's not always as smooth as it should be. This is especially true for long-time software users who rely on older versions, such as Adobe InDesign CS4. When I upgraded to macOS High Sierra, I was faced with a frustrating issue: my InDesign files opened to blank pages and the tool panel disappeared. This article explores the challenges faced by users who encounter these issues and provides potential solutions.

The Problem

When I installed macOS High Sierra, I didn't expect my go-to InDesign app to behave unpredictably, showing me nothing but blank pages and missing tools. This isn't just a one-off issue; it's a common problem among users of older Adobe software. Adobe, unfortunately, has no plans to 'fix' the incompatibility. Users are left with limited options to make these older programs compatible.

Only Solutions

There are only a few viable solutions to this problem:

Downgrade Your Mac to a Previous OS: You can revert to an earlier version of macOS that is compatible with your CS4 InDesign files. This is a quick fix but might not be ideal for those who want to stay up-to-date with the latest security and performance improvements. Upgrade to Adobe CC: An alternative is to upgrade to the latest version of Adobe Creative Cloud, which is compatible with macOS High Sierra. This can be a more expensive route but ensures that you have the latest features and security updates. Substitute Applications: Another option is to use other software for your design needs. For instance, you can use Affinity Photo and Affinity Designer for Photoshop and Illustrator tasks, respectively. This solution can be more convenient, especially if your specific design requirements are met by these alternative applications.

The Reality of Compatibility

Adobe's decision not to 'fix' the compatibility issue with CS4 InDesign and macOS High Sierra highlights the challenges faced by users of older software. The difficulty is made more apparent by the fact that Adobe has no plans to address this problem in the future. This leaves users in a difficult position, particularly those who need to stay on the latest macOS version for other reasons but can't afford to move their older software to a newer version.

Alternatives for Adobe Acrobat Pro

One piece of software, Adobe Acrobat Pro, presents a unique challenge. As of my last update, there are no viable solutions for using this with macOS High Sierra, leaving users in a bit of a dilemma. This is where the option to downgrade your Mac to an earlier OS becomes even more crucial, as older versions of macOS might still be able to run Adobe Acrobat Pro without significant issues.

Is Upgrading to macOS High Sierra Worth It?

As for the broader question of whether to upgrade to macOS High Sierra, the answer is not a straightforward yes or no. On one hand, you might be missing out on the latest security updates, features, and performance improvements. On the other hand, you might also face compatibility issues with older software, which can lead to frustration and lost productivity.

Conclusion

For users of Adobe InDesign CS4, the journey to macOS High Sierra can be a bumpy one. The incompatibility issue is a reality that must be faced. Whether you choose to downgrade, upgrade to Adobe CC, or use alternative software, the decision ultimately comes down to your specific needs and the trade-offs you're willing to make. It's a challenging period for those stuck between a rock and a hard place, but with careful consideration, you can find a solution that works for you.