Navigating the Evolution of Adobe Creative Suits: CS5 vs. CC for Comic and Manga Artists
In the world of digital illustration and comic design, the transition from Adobe Creative Suite (CS) to Creative Cloud (CC) has marked a significant shift in the industry. This change comes with diverse implications, particularly for those who specialize in manga and comics. This article aims to dissect the key differences between Adobe CS5 and CC, focusing on their suitability for comic and manga artists.
The Transition from CS to CC
The transition from Adobe Creative Suite (CS) to Creative Cloud (CC) signifies the advent of a subscription-based model, replacing the earlier non-subscription versions of Adobe applications. Unlike the fixed one-time purchase of CS suites, CC apps require a continuous subscription. Thus, the pricing model is a pivotal factor for artists considering upgrading their software.
Pricing and Subscription Models
Considering the pricing, Photoshop offers a subscription-only model. The cost varies, but starting at $9.99/month it allows users to access the latest features and continuous updates. The complete Creative Cloud suite, which includes a range of applications like Photoshop, Illustrator, InDesign, etc., can be more expensive ranging up to $49.99/month, depending on the subscription plan.
Historical Context and Development
The majority of guides and tutorials for using Photoshop in manga and comic authoring were created during the era of Photoshop 6 through Photoshop CS3. From a production standpoint, there hasn't been substantial improvement since then. Many artists who continue to use CC subscriptions do so primarily for compatibility with modern macOS, rather than for new features added specifically for manga artists. In fact, certain features that manga artists have relied on, such as 3D-related functionality, have been removed.
Clips Studio Paint has gained popularity due to its inbuilt settings for manga and comic artists, making it easier and more efficient for their workflow. On the other hand, Photoshop requires additional setup for manga or comic production, which can be time-consuming. For instance, setting up pattern brushes and other workflow-related customizations are necessary but not as straightforward.
Adoption of Photoshop CS5
While Adobe CS5 remains a solid choice for comic and manga artists, it offers everything they need for common productions. It is particularly suitable for those who value stability and do not require frequent updates or the latest features. CS5's robust set of tools is still applicable and effective for most comic and manga designs.
Generative Fills and Beyond
Manga and comic artists should pay particular attention to the evolution of generative fills, a feature that has seen significant improvements. These advanced fills can save a lot of time and provide more creative control. However, it is important to address the potential copyright concerns that arise with using these features. Artists must ensure that any designs they create do not infringe on existing copyrights or trademarks.
Conclusion
The shift from Adobe CS5 to CC presents a nuanced choice for manga and comic artists. While CC offers the latest features and continuous updates, the steep subscription cost and the need for ongoing subscription can be a deterrent. For those who prioritize compatibility with modern systems and do not require frequent updates, Adobe CS5 remains a reliable option. Ultimately, the choice depends on an artist's specific needs and budget.