Optimizing Your First Bookshelf Speaker System: Size and Quality Considerations
In the realm of home audio systems, bookshelf speakers are a popular choice, especially for enthusiasts who wish to create a balanced and powerful sound system without the need for extensive space. This article explores the best size options for your first bookshelf speaker system, particularly in the context of enhancing sound quality. While brands like Onkyo offer quality products, the discussion here is more focused on the factors that influence speaker size and performance.When considering the size of a bookshelf speaker, it's crucial to understand that smaller speakers inherently have limitations compared to their larger counterparts. Firstly, it's important to recognize that bookshelf speakers, as their name suggests, are designed to be compact and portable, fitting neatly on bookshelves. However, this compactness brings with it trade-offs. The primary factor to consider is the balance between size and sound quality.
Choosing the Right Size for Your Bookshelf Speakers
When shopping for bookshelf speakers, especially if you're interested in Onkyo models, it's essential to visit a reputable audio dealer. This allows you to listen to various speakers that meet your requirements. Ideally, these speakers should be set up on a similar structure to your bookshelves, giving you a more accurate idea of their performance. However, if a demo setup isn't available, borrowing a pair and trying them out at home can provide the most authentic experience.
The size of your choice should not only be based on aesthetics but also on the quality of sound you are seeking. Large speakers tend to excel in providing better bass, while smaller speakers, when of high quality, can offer excellent imaging. Interestingly, "bookshelf" speakers often perform best on open stands, positioned at ear level, rather than on shelves. This suggests that for optimal performance, it might be beneficial to elevate your bookshelf speakers slightly for better sound quality.
Compromises and Alternatives
To achieve a well-rounded sound system, one effective approach is to combine a pair of large subwoofers for extended bass with smaller satellite speakers that handle the musical range and high frequencies. Top-tier sound systems often employ low-distortion arrays of multiple speakers, each dedicated to a specific frequency range. These systems are frequently arranged in columns with controlled dispersion, along with robust subwoofers. For those with the necessary tools, resources, and expertise, building DIY speakers can be a cost-effective alternative to pre-assembled systems.
A proven successful design is a single cabinet that is larger at the bottom for bass and smaller at the top for better imaging. Another option is column-shaped floor-standing speakers with subwoofers at the bottom and music-range speakers and tweeters at the top. These designs offer a compromise between size and performance, balancing bass depth and clarity effectively.
Active vs. Passive Speakers: A Closer Look
In the world of bookshelf speakers, both active and passive options are available, each with its advantages and disadvantages. An active speaker system requires less additional hardware, as it contains its own amplifier and driver. A popular choice for active speakers is the Rokit 5 or the Tascam models, known for their musicality. On the other hand, passive speakers need an external amplifier and preamp, but the reputation of brands like Bose can provide a safety net as their technology is generally reliable.
Regardless of whether you opt for an active or passive system, the key is to listen and evaluate the performance before making a final decision. The best approach is to experiment with different configurations and sizes to find the setup that provides the sound quality and balance you desire. Remember, the right size and configuration can significantly enhance your listening experience, regardless of the brand you choose.