The Disadvantages of Mechanical Keyboards: Cost and Noise

While mechanical keyboards offer a range of advantages such as more solid and accurate keystrokes, better build quality, and a more satisfying typing experience, there are also several downsides to consider, particularly in terms of cost and noise. In this article, we will explore these disadvantages and help you make an informed decision based on your specific needs.

Higher Cost

One of the most significant downsides of mechanical keyboards is their higher cost. This issue was particularly pronounced a few years ago when Cherry held a strong monopoly on the mechanical keyboard switch market. As a result, the cost of individual switches was significantly higher than their production costs, making mechanical keyboards relatively expensive to produce. However, with the entry of other companies that offer comparable switches at lower prices, the overall cost of mechanical keyboards has dropped. Even so, they still tend to be more expensive than their membrane keyboard counterparts, especially in the higher-end models.

Unlike membrane keyboards, which can be found for as little as $20, mechanics typically start at around $50 and can go up to several hundred dollars. The high cost is due to the use of individual mechanical switches, sturdyconstruction, premium materials, and sometimes special features like RGB lighting. For many consumers, especially those looking for a budget-friendly option, this higher cost can be a major drawback.

Noise and Usability

Another significant downside of mechanical keyboards is their tendency to be noisier than membrane keyboards. Mechanical keyboards produce noise every time a key is pressed due to the direct mechanical contact between the switch and the keycap. While some switches like linear or tactile switches can be quite quiet, the #8220;clicky#8221; switches, which involve a distinct clicking sound, can be quite loud. This can be problematic in shared spaces, quiet work environments, or during presentations.

For tasks that require extreme quiet, such as during a presentation or in a library, the noise level of mechanical keyboards can be a serious issue. Mechanical keyboards are also not as #8220;lightweight#8221; as membrane keyboards, which means that they may feel slightly heavier and require a bit more effort to use. This can be particularly noticeable if you are using paper in conjunction with a typewriter, as mechanical keyboards are designed more for typing on a digital device.

Long-Term Benefits vs. Initial Costs

Despite the drawbacks, many users find that the long-term benefits of mechanical keyboards outweigh the initial cost. The durability of mechanical switches can last for millions of keystrokes, leading to lower long-term costs and a longer lifespan compared to membrane keyboards, which are more prone to wear and tear. Mechanical keyboards also offer a more customizable and user-serviceable experience, allowing users to customize switch options, keycaps, and even build their own keyboards if they so desire.

Pros:

Fruzsy and satisfying typing experience Facilitates long typing sessions Facilitates rapid response in gaming Typically higher quality and more durable More customizable and user-serviceable

Cons:

Loud and audible even in quiet settings Expensive with prices starting at $50 and going up to several hundred dollars Risk of requiring extensive research before making a purchase

Ultimately, the choice between a mechanical and a membrane keyboard comes down to personal preference and specific needs. For those who require a more satisfying and durable typing experience and are willing to invest in the higher costs and potential noise levels, mechanical keyboards can be a great choice. However, for those looking for a more budget-friendly and quiet option, membrane keyboards may be a better fit.