The Nikon D750 vs. Canon 5D Mark III: A Comprehensive Comparison for Video Enthusiasts

When choosing a camera for video, understanding the differences between the Nikon D750 and the Canon 5D Mark III is crucial. This article aims to provide a detailed comparison of these two models, helping videographers make an informed decision based on their specific needs.

Key Differentiators: Firmware and Software Capabilities

The main difference between Canon and Nikon when it comes to videography lies in their firmware and software capabilities. Magic Lantern, a popular firmware platform, is exclusive to Canon cameras. This firmware provides users with additional functions, including the ability to shoot RAW video, which offers unparalleled image quality.

In contrast, Nikon's software is known to be harder to hack. While this may initially seem like a drawback, it opens up a range of useful features for users who prioritize ease of use and stability. When it comes to raw video shooting, Nikon's D750 offers this capability through an external recorder like those from Atomos or Blackmagic. However, this comes at the cost of significantly increased storage requirements.

Video Quality and Recording Options

The Nikon D750 truly shines when recording through HDMI to an external recorder. In such settings, it becomes possible to shoot video without RAW, opting instead for uncompressed ProRes or DNxHD in 422 format. This flexibility in recording modes adds to the camera's versatility.

However, it's worth noting that the Nikon D750 can only fully showcase its video quality when connected externally. If you're working directly with the camera's internal recording, the quality may be suboptimal. This is something to consider if you're planning to do any serious video production.

Ownership and Practical Considerations

While the D750 is user-friendly, it's important to acknowledge its shortcomings. The body is geared more towards the prosumer market, and it includes displays with effects and scene settings that may seem unnecessary or even annoying to some users. A more programmable user interface would have been a significant improvement.

If you decide to purchase the D750, be aware that it may suffer from internal lighting artifacts. This issue can be addressed by installing a firmware update provided free of charge by Nikon. Additionally, ensure that you are aware of the trade-offs and limitations of the camera before making a purchase decision.

Performance and Build Quality

Both the Nikon D750 and the Canon 5D Mark III are highly regarded in the video community. The D750 is praised for its superior image quality, especially when compared to the EOS 5D Mark III. In fact, DxO rated the D750 as one of the best full-frame DSLRs of all time. While both cameras excel in raw shooting, they both still struggle with contrast autofocus, a common issue in the DSLR market.

The Nikon D750 offers 1080/60p video, which is not supported by the Canon 5D Mark III. If you're capturing fast-moving content, this higher frame rate is a significant advantage. It allows you to shoot with a smooth, cinematic feel without the need to drop to lower frame rates, such as 720/60p.

Alternative Choices

While the Nikon D750 and the Canon 5D Mark III are both excellent choices, it's worth considering other options as well. The Panasonic GH4, for instance, is a standalone camera that excels in both still and video capabilities. Panasonic is not known for its prosumer pricing, but their products offer a great value proposition.

In conclusion, while both the Nikon D750 and the Canon 5D Mark III are top-tier video cameras, the choice ultimately depends on your specific needs and budget. The D750's ability to shoot high-quality external video and its 1080/60p capability make it a powerful tool for videographers, but it's essential to weigh the trade-offs and potential limitations. For those seeking a camera that excels in stills and video without the compromises, the Panasonic GH4 might be a better option.

Understanding the nuances between these cameras will help you make the best decision for your videography needs.