Understanding Arsh Mishra's Perspective on Umang Taneja's Method of Calculating Longevity

In the world of Vedic astrology, particularly Key Point (KP) astrology, the method of calculating longevity has garnered considerable attention. Arsh Mishra and Umang Taneja both contribute unique insights, but their methods may not be as distinct as one might initially think. This article delves into a comparative analysis of their views, focusing on the KP method of assessing longevity.

The KP Method of Judging Longevity

According to the KP method, longevity is primarily judged using the following houses:

1st House: Body and general health 5th House: Longevity 9th House: Longevity and success 10th House: Career and social success 11th House: Income and financial stability

Conversely, unhealthy and shorter lifespans are often associated with:

6th House: Illness and enemies 8th House: Life-threatening events and accidents 12th House: Long-term illness and loss of wealth or property

Arsh Mishra mentions that Umang Taneja does not include the 3rd and 8th houses in the assessment of longevity, which is a common practice in KP astrology. These houses are traditionally considered significant for longevity, while the 12th house is associated with death.

The Theoretical Foundation

The theoretical background for judging longevity using the KP method is rooted in long-standing usage and validation. KP astrology often aligns with traditional astrological concepts, although slight modifications or personal touches might be added by practitioners.

For instance, the 3rd and 8th houses are recognized as houses of longevity and are not typically excluded. However, the 12th house is traditionally considered a Maraka Sthana, or a house associated with death, and is therefore included in longevity calculations.

Practical Application in Astrology

Prashna karma (query-based astrology) and horoscopic astrology (natal charts) provide different perspectives on longevity assessment.

Prashna Karma

Prashna karma involves answering specific questions about a particular event or situation. When predicting longevity, if the person is likely to die soon, the planets align with dushtanas (malefic houses). If they will live, the planets align with kendra (angular) and trine (succedent) houses. This method is simpler and more straightforward as it focuses directly on the event in question.

Natal Chart Analysis

Analysis of a natal chart, on the other hand, involves a more complex process. The prediction of longevity in a natal chart is not as precise, as it requires understanding the entire life journey of the individual. Factors such as the ascendant, the overall pattern of the horoscope, and the strength of planets and signs must be considered. Determining the exact age of death through these methods can be a challenging task, involving multiple steps and calculations.

The Indicators of Longevity

Longevity in astrology goes beyond just the placement of certain houses. Each position in the horoscope, every sign in a particular house, and every planet in a particular house and sign contributes to the overall assessment of longevity.

The process involves:

Evaluating the ascendant and the overall pattern of the horoscope Assessing the strength of planets and signs Placements of longevity- related houses and signs Determination of marakas (malefic planets) and the periods (dashas) they rule Working out transits to determine the periods of potential death

Once all these factors are considered, a timeline for the periods of potential death can be established. This timeline is subject to the indications of longevity, meaning that a person's natural lifespan can only be significantly shortened by calamities or disasters.

It is important to note that even the strongest marakas cannot cause death before a person's lifespan is determined by the overall indicators in their horoscope.

Conclusion

While Arsh Mishra and Umang Taneja offer unique perspectives, the KP method of assessing longevity is rooted in a well-established theoretical framework. The traditional houses and techniques used in KP astrology, including the use of the 3rd, 8th, and 12th houses, provide a comprehensive and accurate method for predicting longevity. Understanding these concepts can help astrologers and enthusiasts make more informed predictions.

In summary, a thorough understanding of KP astrology is key to accurately predicting longevity. The complexity of horoscope analysis, combined with the theoretical underpinnings of KP, ensures that these predictions are both detailed and reliable.