Which Laptop is Better: Asus TUF A15 AMD Ryzen 5-4600H 4GB or MSI GL65 Intel Core i7-9750H 6GB?
When it comes to choosing between the Asus TUF A15 with an AMD Ryzen 5-4600H 4GB GPU and the MSI GL65 with an Intel Core i7-9750H 6GB GPU, it's not a straightforward answer. The choice depends on your specific needs, such as whether you prioritize a better CPU or a better GPU.
Comparing the CPUs and GPUs
The Ryzen 5 4600H is slightly faster than the i7-9750H but uses less power. Both have the same thermal design power (TDP), but the actual power usage is lower for the Ryzen 5 4600H. However, the GTX 1660 Ti laptop GPU is significantly more powerful than the GTX 1650 Ti GPU, making it a better choice for gamers.
Game Performance and Price
Given the significantly higher gaming power of the GTX 1660 Ti compared to the 1650 Ti, the second laptop is a more powerful option for gaming. At a price point that is quite substantial, the choice of the MSI GL65 is more justified. The MSI GL65 features an Intel Core i7-9750H 6GB GPU, which is a more balanced and powerful option compared to the older and less potent GPUs.
Thermal Design and Build Quality
Several factors make the second laptop a more attractive option. For starters, the MSI GL65 has a denser cooling design and a more reliable processor. The 9th generation Intel Core i7-9750H might not be the most recent, but it is still a robust processor that is well-suited for a variety of tasks.
When it comes to the Asus TUF A15, its thermal design has been criticized for its inefficiency. The simpler ventilation system can lead to higher temperatures, which may impact the stability and performance of the machine. This is particularly noteworthy if you want a laptop that you can carry around, as the thermal throttling can significantly cut into your performance.
For those who can afford to open up the laptop and strategically place ventilation holes, the Asus TUF A15 might be a viable option. However, for the average user, the MSI GL65 is likely the better investment, with its superior performance and build quality.
Conclusion
Both laptops offer top-notch performance, but with some caveats. The MSI GL65 with its Intel Core i7-9750H and GTX 1660 Ti is a more balanced and powerful option. It's better suited for gaming and day-to-day use, with its more efficient thermal design and better long-term performance. The Asus TUF A15, on the other hand, is not as reliable when it comes to heat management, making it a less desirable choice for those who prioritize portability and consistent performance.