Which is Better: MSI vs Alienware Gaming Laptops
When it comes to choosing between MSI and Alienware gaming laptops, the decision can be a nuanced one, largely dependent on your priorities. This article provides a comprehensive comparison, highlighting the strengths and weaknesses of both brands, to help you make an informed choice.
Performance and Specifications
MSI offers more specced laptops with superior performance under load, though they generate higher noise from their fans and higher CPU and GPU temperatures. In contrast, Alienware’s laptops provide better customer service and build quality, particularly during the build process. These factors are crucial if you value immediate satisfaction and professional support.
However, if design aesthetics are a significant factor, MSI lags slightly behind Alienware. The Alienware GP66 is generally considered the clear winner in terms of design, featuring the thinnest models among the options available. MSI's GP66 does come with the advantage of a 120/144 Hz screen and a SteelSeries per-key RGB keyboard, which enhances user experience and visual appeal.
Build Quality and Polish
Alienware edges slightly ahead of MSI in overall build quality. Dell, the parent company of Alienware, is renowned for making incredible laptops, and the Alienware versions are highly similar in build quality. MSI, on the other hand, excels in offering the best value for money, by including advanced features such as 120/144 Hz screens and SteelSeries per-key RGB keyboards.
Both brands offer impressive deals on 17-inch gaming laptops. The Alienware AW17R5 is available for a competitive price of $1350, featuring a GTX 1060 with 8GB DDR4 and a 60Hz monitor. Meanwhile, the MSI GE73 Raider, priced at $1630, comes with a GTX 1070, 16GB DDR4, and a 120Hz screen. Both laptops include an Intel i7–8750H processor, 256GB NVMe SSD, and 1TB HDD.
Experience and Initial Setup
When considering an initial out-of-the-box experience and office aesthetics, the Alienware AW17R5 might be the preferred choice. Its look and feel are generally more polished, and it provides a better visual impression in the office. Conversely, if you value a deeper gaming experience with a smoother, faster screen refresh rate, the MSI GE73 Raider is the optimal choice, especially in settings where performance is paramount.
Historical Context and Brand Evolution
Both MSI and Alienware have evolved significantly over the years. In the early days, MSI was primarily known for motherboards and cheap GPUs, placing it in the third tier of consumer choices. Over time, MSI has improved its product lineup, offering a range of options suitable for both budget-conscious and high-end gaming enthusiasts.
Today, both brands compete on a more level playing field, with Alienware solidly backed by Dell and MSI aiming to meet the demand for both high-value and budget-friendly gaming laptops. For gamers seeking the best bang for their buck, MSI still offers compelling options, while Alienware prioritizes premium features and initial setup ease.
Ultimately, the decision between MSI and Alienware depends on your personal preferences, budget, and priorities. If you value superior performance, MSI might be the better choice. However, if tailored customer service and build quality are non-negotiables, Alienware could be the way to go.