Why You Don't Need a Screen Protector: The Case Against Them
When it comes to protecting your phone from accidental falls and scratches, many argue that a screen protector is a necessity. However, this article explores why you might not need one and discusses the drawbacks of using a screen protector.
The Drawbacks of Using a Screen Protector
Despite their popularity, screen protectors can often do more harm than good. Firstly, they can focus the force of impact on a single point, leading to increased chances of cracking. While a screen protector is simple to replace and reasonably priced, it does not offer complete protection. A strong enough impact can still crack your screen, especially when a protective layer is not properly applied.
Tactile and Visual Discomfort
Screen protectors can significantly alter how your display feels to the touch. Since plastic does not have the same tactile feel as glass, it can interfere with the user experience. Glass screen covers have become increasingly popular due to their better touch and design aesthetics. Additionally, placing a layer of plastic or thin glass between you and your device’s screen can slightly alter its appearance, especially if the screen protector discolours over time.
Screen protectors are generally less durable than Gorilla Glass or Ceramic Shield, often picking up unsightly scratches that would not have been visible on your phone’s screen. This is particularly true if the protector is not applied properly, leading to bubbles and cracks that necessitate replacement.
Personal Experiences and Insights
For many individuals, using a screen protector is not a necessity. Some users, like myself, handle devices carefully and have never experienced a dropped phone. However, it is important to note that this does not apply to all device owners. Family members might be less careful, leading them to rely on cases for added protection.
One user, who has been using a tempered glass screen protector on their OP5T, argues that it is a non-issue. They claim that the positives outweigh the negatives, using a screen protector from Olixar that is barely noticeable. The user asserts that they have never experienced a broken screen while using a tempered glass protector, and that it has even saved their phone multiple times. They recommend against taking the risk of damaging the screen and do not use phone insurance.
Another perspective comes from those who handle their devices with care. For instance, the user who has used iPhones from the 3GS to the X has never needed a screen protector and has never experienced a screen break. This suggests that for users who are careful with their devices, a screen protector might not be necessary.
Conclusion
The necessity of a screen protector ultimately depends on the user and their handling habits. While some might find it a non-issue and even advantageous, others might prefer the tactile and visual experience of a naked screen. Regardless of the choice, it's important to weigh the benefits and drawbacks carefully and make a decision that suits your specific needs.